logo

search

  • Home
  • About
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
delete
bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark

Top Five Reasons why Vinyl will outlive CDs

Posted by Flick in Opinions on 10 8th, 2007 | View Comments

IMG_9862.JPG Reason #1: Vinyl has outlived every other physical music medium.

Vinyl records have been manufactured in eight formats since 1894. During the past 113 years, the music industry has seen numerous formats rise and fall. Consider the media formats that have come and gone: reel-to-reel, eight tracks, cassette tapes, mini-discs.

In 1948 the first 12 inch vinyl record was manufactured, solidifying the concept of the album. For the first time, listeners could enjoy 23 minutes of continuous music without having to flip the album over or load the next single. Artists began to record numerous songs, typically 14, and packaged them together as one concept. Other music formats continued this approach, but none have fully embodied the album concept in the same way that vinyl has.

Reason #2: CDs will soon be abandoned.

Growth in digital downloads will begin to outpace the decline in CD sales in a few years, especially since iTunes will begin to face stiff competition from Amazon and the various digital stores that EMI and Universal are nurturing. Once the major labels begin to believe that CDs need to be abandoned due to slumping numbers, they will whole heartedly embrace digital downloads. If you don’t believe me, think back to the death of cassette tapes when CDs became widely available.

Reason #3: Digital downloads are being packaged with purchases of vinyl.

When The Arcade Fire released Neon Bible, they offered a digital download with every purchase of their vinyl. On December 3, Radiohead will ship a “discbox” that will include two vinyl records, one CD, an enhanced CD, and a digital download of In Rainbows, and a digital download of bonus tracks. Vinyl record sales have increased 10% since 2004, and I predict that this trend will only continue.

Reason #4: Album collectors tend to prefer Vinyl over every other physical format.

While consumers are turning to digital downloads to listen to their music so they can upload tracks to their 160gb iPod, collectors continue to prefer vinyl as their format of choice. Ask any music collector and they’ll explain why vinyl sounds better than CDs due to its warmth. They’ll also express a passion for the album art, pointing out that CD booklets lacked in comparison.

Reason #5: Consumers view music as something they access, not own.

As albums are leaked months in advance of their release dates on peer-to-peer networks, fewer people are willing to pay for something they can access for free. Instead, the emphasis is shifting back to live performances as ticket sales have doubled. Massive music collections fill the hard drives of countless college students who gladly share files with their friends. The availability of music is beginning to change the mindset of music as something we access rather than own, whether consumers subscribe to a service such as Rhapsody, or if they download Mp3s from their friends. Access versus ownership is the real reason the CD is no longer relevant to consumers.

The Pendletons – Put That Record On

Digg this story

Random Posts

    • http://musicarticles.info/?p=16626 Music » Top Five Reasons why Vinyl will outlive CDs

      [...] unknown wrote an interesting post today onHere’s a quick excerptOther music formats continued this approach, but none have fully embodied the album concept in the same way that vinyl has. Reason #2: CDs will soon be abandoned. Growth in digital downloads will begin to outpace the decline in CD sales … [...]

    • http://www.pampelmoose.com Dave Allen

      Flick, very fine points. Vinyl is awesome and still the best sounding medium for listening to music in my opinion. I also have to agree with your thoughts on the end of the cd – coincidentally our thoughts cross paths, I wrote an opinion piece for one of our newspapers and posted in my ‘essays’ blog here http://www.pampelmoose.com/sparks/?p=69

      Dave http://www.pampelmoose.com

    • http://www.pampelmoose.com/mspeaks/?p=1056 pampelmoose » Dave Allen of Gang of Four’s Music and Media Blog » puddlegum – top 5 reasons why vinyl will outlive cds

      [...] Flick over at Puddlegum has a fine overview regarding what he sees as the end of the CD era. And his 5 points are: – Vinyl has outlived every other physical music medium. – CDs will soon be abandoned. – Digital downloads are being packaged with purchases of vinyl. – Album collectors tend to prefer Vinyl over every other physical format. – Consumers view music as something they access, not own. Read and comment on the article here. [...]

    • http://www.thankscaptainobvious.net Royce aka: Capt. Obvious

      There’s something about vinyl that gives it staying power. You can’t compete with the sound of a records, and there is just something magical about having the artwork in “12 form as well as the feeling of putting the needle down on a record for the first time. I can’t imagine ever selling my record collection, but I’m constantly getting rid of my CD’s. I have most of my music in digital format and on my ipod, yet I seek out my favorite albums on vinyl. Well written article flick.

    • http://www.APigeonCalledFrank.com APigeonCalledFrank

      i completely agree. i’ve been collecting records since i was 8 and have amassed quite a collection. But it’s not just an obssesive collectors thing that makes vinyl great. There are just some things that cannot be found on CDs or even downloads. Like a very rare record with a limited pressing that no one thinks of burning.

      But most of all, i value my collection (as i’m sure most of you do) because i know that the whole room full of amazing music will be passed on from generation to generation who will discover all these great artists. Much better than just handing your grandkids a little 160gb iPod, yeah?
      =)

    • http://www.collectingvinylrecords.com Robert Benson

      Lovely post and I can agree with everything mentioned. But, I want to add one more to the list-Vinyl Art. Album cover art is one of the most fascinating aspects about the LP, with many famous artists (i.e. R. Crumb, Andy Warhol and many more) lending their expertise and talents to make beautiful art. In fact, I am a collector and I will purchasae an album just for the cover art, and I am sure I am not the only one :)

      Regards,
      Robert
      http://www.collectingvinylrecords.com

    • Vinyl-Lover

      I must say I agree with all the posts, especially Bob’s about the cover art. I also have been collecting vinyl since the mid-60′s and now have a decent sized collection. I love to check out the artwork and read the liner notes, plus the Inner Sleeves that Columbia used to use to give you info about other albums that were available at the time. And, like Bob, I have bought many an album just because the cover was interesting. In fact, I am a huge Barclay James Harvest fan, and first bought their “Gone To Earth” album because of the cover! Sometimes you win, and sometimes the artwork is the only good thing about the album.

    • http://Deltachord.tennerblog.com/2007/11/06/grooving-with-vinyl-or-digital-is-king/ Deltachord » Blog Archive » Grooving With Vinyl or Digital is King

      [...] http://puddlegum.net/top-five-reasons-why-vinyl-will-outlive-cds/ http://slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=07/10/29/1947253&from=rss [...]

    • http://abortmag.com/?p=6138 » Top Five Reasons why Vinyl will outlive CDs ABORT Magazine™ – Terminate…The Intolerable.

      [...] (Source – PuddleGum) [...]

    • Derel Surki

      I think the music industry may be willing to go back to Vinyl for another reason….its hard to pirate Vinyl records! I mean with a CD, I rip it to my computer, save the files on another disk or flash drive and give them to anyone I want. I can also go to the library and rip a CD and return it while still having the album…you can’t do that with a Vinyl record.

    • zootallures

      Are we forgetting the fact that vinyl’s sound is created by running a sharp needle over a plastic surface? Every time you play a record, you’re degrading the item. A CD, on the other hand, only gets scratched if you’re a bumbling fool….

    • mike brown

      well-i never thought vinyl would regain it,s popularity-its the best period. the best music came along while vinyl was all there was-beatles,carpenters, eagles and lot more from bands to instrumemtals. that is very under discussed to me-todays music is mostly crap but, to be fair ideas are not available like the beatles had– they put out so many different great medolies that has not been matched-and rap crap–that,s not even music-one thing at least–you don,t have to be able to sing to do that shit. the last great song i heard was theme from pearlharhor 2001 from the movie-though the best music today comes from movies to me– song from movie gran tarino-great and sad-oh well sorry i got on high horse about music instead of vinyl over cd-computer downloads,etc. i wish it was the60,s no cd,s no puters for home use and the rotary phone–glad i was here then as a teenager to witness the beatles on sullivan and the moon landing–young people today missed the greatest decade of all i hate to say–it’s all just my opinion i know

    blog comments powered by Disqus

    about us

    Puddlegum began in 1997 as one of the first online music magazines. It is managed by Flick, and has gained respect from many in the recording industry.

    Over the years Puddlegum has accomplished quite a few things we are proud of:
    Being mentioned by Thom Yorke during a BBC Radio interview (concerning our Tens Theory), and being written about in Rolling Stone. We have also made the front page of TUAW, Digg, and VH1’s Best Week Ever, and have been featured on USA Today, and Reuters.

    Contact Flick by phone: (574)386-0851
    email: flick@puddlegum.net
    AIM: pooroldflick

    recent posts

    Implications of Facebook Music...
    Surprised by the Amazon Cloud Player...
    Thom Yorke: If you think this is everything, you&#...
    Sleeping Bag: Slime...
    Music radio may be dead, but music curation lives ...

    recent comments

    • Online Furniture Stores:  Philadelphia-based East Hundred play melodic pop/rock with...
    • Cheap Flights to Beirut: Beirut is rich in natural beauty but the war demolished it. ...
    • Hinckley home value: As we get older, we usually have good advice for young paren...
    • 0845 numbers: Bluetooth technology does come with its benefits, though. As...
    • Snowy: You obviously need to lighten up a tad...
    • Jake: The article forgot to mention that you are supposed to cross...

    Email updates! Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    Sponsors

    Puddlegum Listening Party

    Send us your track Join the Puddlegum Listening Party!

    Blogosphere Links

    • FrozenBlog
    • Said the Gramophone
    • headphone sex
    • RecProAudio
    • Obsessive Music Disorder
    © Copyright Puddlegum 2010. All rights reserved. | Powered by Wordpress | Designed by Elegant Themes
    Are you looking for a USB Microphone, or a Tablet PC?